| Platinum | American Legion Elgin Post 57 |
| Gold | The Walnut Speak Easy |
| Silver | Old Republic Kitchen + Bar |
| Bronze | Bandito Barney's Beach Club |
| Top Pick | Dutch Inn West |
| Top Pick | Fatzos |
| Top Pick | Martini Room Elgin |
| Top Pick | Plank Road Tap Room |
| Top Pick | River Street Tavern |
| Top Pick | The Haight |