| Platinum | Danny's on Douglas |
| Gold | Mel's Pizza |
| Silver | Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria |
| Bronze | Rogue's Corner |
| Top Pick | Cafe Roma |
| Top Pick | Geno Nottolini's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Nick's Pizza & Pub |
| Top Pick | Village Pizza and Pub |
| Top Pick | White Cottage Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Wise Guys Pizzeria |