| Platinum | El Faro |
| Platinum | Sammy's Mexican Grill |
| Gold | El Paraiso |
| Silver | El Cokito |
| Bronze | Carmina's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Carmina's Restaurant & Banquet |
| Top Pick | Coronado Mexican Kitchen And Margarita House |
| Top Pick | El Molino Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Los Fernandez |
| Top Pick | Sammy's |