| Platinum | Old Republic Kitchen + Bar |
| Gold | Al's Cafe & Creamery |
| Silver | Red Poppy Bistro |
| Bronze | Elgin Public House |
| Top Pick | Bennigan's |
| Top Pick | Cafe Roma |
| Top Pick | Danny's on Douglas |
| Top Pick | Mozzafiato |
| Top Pick | Paul's Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Ray's Family Restaurant |